The earlier, the better
The single most important factor in estate mediation outcomes is timing. Disputes resolved early — before proceedings are filed, before positions harden, and before significant legal costs have been incurred — settle more easily and at better outcomes for all parties. Once Supreme Court proceedings are underway, costs escalate rapidly and settlement becomes psychologically harder.
Key triggers that indicate it's time for mediation
- A family member indicates they intend to make a family provision claim
- Beneficiaries are in dispute about asset distribution or property values
- There is a challenge to the executor's conduct or decision-making
- A dispute about will validity is emerging and the parties wish to avoid the reputational and relational damage of contested litigation
- The estate is holding assets (such as real property) that cannot be distributed until the dispute is resolved — mediation resolves the blockage
Court-ordered mediation
In New South Wales, the Supreme Court refers most family provision matters to mediation within months of filing — often before the first contested hearing. In Victoria and Queensland, courts similarly order or encourage mediation. Parties who wait for a court order lose the opportunity to resolve the matter at lower cost through private mediation first.
Time limits for family provision claims
Family provision claims must be filed within 12 months of the date of death in NSW and most other states. Filing proceedings to protect the limitation period does not prevent the parties from mediating — but it is important not to let mediation delay result in a claim being time-barred. A potential claimant can attempt mediation and file proceedings simultaneously, or file first and then mediate.
What about disputes that arise during administration?
Not all estate disputes are about wills — many arise during the administration of an estate (executor decisions, delays, asset valuations, interim distributions). These disputes suit mediation at any stage of administration. Resolving administration disputes through mediation avoids the cost and delay of beneficiary actions in the Supreme Court.
Sources